What’s the Automatic No? It’s a phenomenon I’ve long observed among many folks with Adult ADHD. (In fact, I seem to have coined the term, writing about it first in 2014 in an article I wrote for CHADD.)
To the uninitiated, the Automatic No might look like negativity or even oppositional defiance. But typically there is more afoot. How do I know this? Two ways:
- Professionally, by developing expertise in Adult ADHD
- Personally, by observing at home and elsewhere
Oh, I’ve also seen the Automatic Yes, too. More about that in a minute.
The Professional Explanation
We could categorize the Automatic No as a “poor coping response.”
That is, when folks grow up without benefit of the ADHD diagnosis or treatment, they tend to come up with all variety of ways to cope with their challenges. Some are positive. Some are counter-productive—and some even destructive. Many “poor coping responses” simply are desperate attempts at getting by day to day—lacking better explanations for their challenges.
Therapy for Adult ADHD should shine a major light on identifying these counterproductive coping responses and, with diagnosis/treatment now in hand, finding more productive coping responses. That was a major focus of my first book and now a major focus of my online training (launches soon, so be sure to subscribe!).
As for the personal, my husband (aka, Dr. Goat) used to be the Master of the Automatic No. Once he was diagnosed with ADHD (in 1999), I started understanding how he developed this habit. When I interviewed him, a few years ago, for an article on his best tips for slowing his own ADHD roller coaster,* I asked him about the Automatic No.
Dr. Goat: The Personal Explanation
At any rate, here is his response to my question:
What’s the Automatic No? Simple. I would routinely say no when my wife would propose an outing or a different way of doing things at home. Who knows why. I wasn’t opposed to most of her suggestions.
Looking back, I suspect I reflexively rejected adding one more thing to the pile I was supposed to think about or remember—possibly resulting in another failure. Most of you know what I mean by this: You grow so accustomed to falling flat when attempting new things that you avoid trying them. I found it easier to say no and go watch Star Trek instead!
Since then, I’ve learned to listen with an open mind before rejecting an idea. Now we have this shtick, in which Gina will suggest something and I’ll say “No.” She’ll repeat it, and I’ll say “No.” She tries one more time, and I often say ‘OK.’
The Automatic Yes: The Other Side of the Coin
A friend of mine diagnosed with ADHD in her 30s has long wrestled with the opposite problem: The Automatic Yes.
Actually, it just seems the opposite problem. It’s really just the flip side of the same challenge: Finding it easier to give a blanket answer rather than think through a response—and risk giving the wrong one. From requests for her to volunteer at her children’s school or babysit her sister’s children, she has trouble saying no.
Yes, she’d call herself a people-pleaser. But if we stop there, we likely miss the core cause.
At the core, ADHD creates trouble for her in distinguishing among tasks she can accommodate versus those that she cannot—or doesn’t want to. Another layer of challenge: She feels she must respond immediately. That means she over-commits, thus disappointing others and herself.
I suggested that she practice saying, “Let me think about it” or “I’ll get back to you”. Or even, putting the onus on the person making the request: “Could you please ask me in a text or e-mail? That way, I’ll be sure to give it thought and get back to you.” This is easier to do now that she’s been taking medication a few years.
Finding The Illusive Middle Ground
Most humans—but especially for humans with ADHD—struggle to find the middle ground on all kinds of issues. For people with ADHD struggling with the fallout from extremes of the Automatic No and the Automatic Yes, solutions start with examining the nature of the response.
In this essay, Taylor J writes about her reaction to reading about these issues in Chapter 3 of Is It You, Me, or Adult A.D.D.?: Chapter 3: Deconstruct Your ADHD Roller CoasterChapter 3: Deconstruct Your ADHD Roller Coaster
Watch The Video
In this video, I touch upon the importance of distinguishing between ADHD symptoms and poor coping responses.
Have You Grappled with ADHD and the Automatic No — or Yes?
Have you made peace with it? What was your strategy? We’d love to know. Just leave a comment!
One Reader Shares Her Perspective:
A reader named Betty shared her concise and insightful experiences with this. To make sure other readers see it, I share it here.
I fluctuate between.
As a child, I survived by doing more than expected so that my failures were lost in the blazing light of accomplishment. It was my responsibility to see that the world was in order.
If my parents fought it was because I failed – and they fought often. I didn’t feel I had the right to say no to any request.
Initially I thought this was a peace-keeping technique, and maybe it was at first. Upon reflection, I began to see the “yes” response, not only as as a validation of my reason for being, but as a prideful response. No one could be as good as I am.
Repeated failures (as a result of saying yes to things I wasn’t equipped to accomplish, or lacking the time, or trying to juggle too much) “no” became my go to response. I said it nicely enough but the result was the same. I got out from under. But I missed out on opportunities to learn, to grow, and too enjoy.
Since my diagnosis, and studying about life with ADHD, I have begun to moderate my approach to requests. Asking questions, assessing current commitments and resources have helped me achieve a more balanced life.
*That article referenced above is: How I Got My Groove Back. Note: I did not write that headline and I still don’t understand it. He was getting a groove for the first time, not getting it back. But read it—it’s good!
Stay posted! Join my mailing list. Look for announcements about online training soon!