Have you heard that “French kids don’t have ADHD?” When I’m feeling up to the challenge, I’ll dip one timid toe into Twitterverse, just to see which ADHD “memes” are trending. Quickly horrified, I hastily retreat—but only after firing a few salvos. Today’s trending post: the virulent (in all senses of the word) “French Kids Don’t Have ADHD” from Psychology Today.
Complex facts are hard to share on Twitter, but I did my best by creating and posting a few “memes,” included in this post. Below I’ll provide the background to support my statement.
When that “French Kids” post first appeared, in 2012, I pegged it as more self-promotional nonsense, the kind we see too often around ADHD. That is, some unknown with a book to sell or a lagging therapy practice to promote decides—Yes! Say something outrageous about ADHD! Because that’s a surefire way to boost notoriety. And for too many profit-driven websites such as Psychology Today‘s, it’s a take-all-comers policy. No editorial judgment required.
Recipe for Getting Attention: Anti-ADHD Style
These sensationalist articles tend to take one of several approaches toward ADHD:
- ADHD is a big hoax.
- ADHD is a pharma conspiracy.
- ADHD is an American invention, handled “without drugs” in more civilized/primitive/etc. countries.
- ADHD is “woefully” over-diagnosed by greedy doctors, parents who don’t want to parent, teachers who don’t want to teach, etc..
- ADHD is best handled with that particular writer’s self-styled guidance, game, or gizmo.
Never mind the thousands of published, peer-reviewed studies on ADHD by legitimate experts. These online, unpaid, self-promoting “columnists” think they know better. Mostly, though, they know how to exploit the public’s ignorance on ADHD to their advantage.
About the “French Kids” Author
The “French Kids” post comes from a Marilyn Wedge, who is on no one’s radar as any kind of psychotherapeutic expert.
She claims to have a practice in Westlake Village, a small community straddling the Los Angeles and Ventura County lines. Her stated Ph.D. is in social psychology, a field quite apart from clinical psychology; it’s much closer to sociology.
One simple definition of social psychology is the study of how people’s thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are influenced by the actual, imaged, or implied the presence of others. Not to knock an entire field of study, but this surely seems a field highly vulnerable to subjective interpretations and fanciful narratives.
On her website, Wedge identifies herself as a licensed marriage and family therapist (MFT). She also claims to have published “numerous professional articles in the field of family therapy.” I searched both PubMed and Google Scholar, and could find only other articles on Psychology Today‘s take-all-clickbait website.
About Psychology Today‘s website: Did you know that basically anyone can post a “column” there? There are apparently no standards—and even less editorial oversight.
The magazine Psychology Today used to be fairly reputable, but that was a very long time ago. It is now little more than a profit vehicle, via ads and its directory (wherein therapists pay to advertise). All the more disturbing: Therapists are allowed to receive continuing-education credits toward their continued licensure, simply for reading Psychology Today articles (and a fee).
Wedge’s other writings include:
About Marilyn Wedge’s Claims
Here’s her first paragraph from the “French Kids” post:
In the United States, at least 9 percent of school-aged children have been diagnosed with ADHD, and are taking pharmaceutical medications. In France, the percentage of kids diagnosed and medicated for ADHD is less than .5 percent. How has the epidemic of ADHD—firmly established in the U.S.—almost completely passed over children in France?
She documents neither these nor the rest of her claims.
First, the 9 percent figure for American kids:
The CDC itself has muddied the statistical waters with the publication of its 2012 survey, in which it found that 9.5% of children age 3-17 years have been diagnosed with ADHD. I’ll save the dissection of that survey for another post; for now, know that those numbers are based on phone surveys of parents, not any type of official clinical tally.
Parent report, the basis of the CDC data, is controversial, known to over-report the prevalence of ADHD. (Sciutto MJ, Eisenberg M. Evaluating the evidence for and against the overdiagnosis of ADHD. J Atten Disord. 2007;11:106-113 and Getahun D, Jacobsen SJ, Fassett MJ, Chen W, Demissie K, Rhoads GG. Recent trends in childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. JAMA Pediatr. 2013;167:282-288.)
Most clinicians have expressed surprise at that high a number (9.5 percent). Without a more centralized system of data-gathering, such as with a national health system, this is how the CDC chose to gather data. As I said, I’ll point out the problems with their methods in the future.
Back to Wedge, with whom I agree on one rare point:
The French do provide more structure for their children. Especially compared to the U.S., with (it must be said) its increasingly lax parenting attitudes and lack of disciplined routines. In France, behavioral expectations also tend to be more typically clear, with unruliness little tolerated. In general.
France also has quite a strong safety net, with admirable child support for working families. And, I’m willing to bet the average French child’s diet is much healthier than is the average American child’s.
But does all this means that French children don’t have ADHD? Or that the structure and discipline they might enjoy in childhood serves to somehow make them higher-functioning for the rest of their lives?
Unfortunately, the facts just don’t bear that out.
Now the “less than .5 percent” for French kids:
Wedge is definitely wrong there, by a mile. As I’ll explain below, the prevalence of ADHD in French children is similar to that of other countries: 3.5 to 5.6 percent.
Why Wedge is Dead Wrong Overall
With this post, I’m not offering a point-by-point counter to Wedge’s claims. Most of her claims can be easily discounted by anyone having a passing familiarity with ADHD. Moreover, her book titles clearly show her anti-psychiatry bent.
Instead, I’m offering two bits of evidence substantiating that French children definitely do have ADHD and also grow up to be adults whose predictable substance-use problems lead to early death.
1. Rates of Substance-Related Deaths in France
Why is this pertinent to ADHD? Because we know that poorly managed ADHD symptoms increase vulnerability to developing substance-use problems.
A sampling from news outlets:
subtitle: “The reputation of the French for drinking in moderation appears slightly misleading after a worrying report released on Monday revealed alcohol is responsible for around 49,000 deaths in France each year – around 134 each day.”
According to the report published by the European Journal of Public Health, alcohol consumption was responsible for the deaths of around 49,000 people.
Catherine Hill, one of the authors of the report summed up the findings simply by saying “the French drink too much”.
The stats, based on the year 2009, revealed that three times as many French men died as a result of an alcohol relate health problem than women.
The study, carried out by the Service for Biostatistics and Epidemiology at the Institue Gustave Roussy, near Paris found that around 36,500 French men die each year from alcohol-related illnesses, around 13 percent of the overall male mortality rate….
Perhaps the most worrying trend the survey revealed was that 40 percent of those deaths were people under the age of 65.
France’s Unhealthy Statistics: A new report has shattered the image of France being a healthy nation despite its fondness for drinking and smoking
The findings reveal that the widespread perception of the French as a healthy nation is rapidly becoming outdated.
A government study, published this month, showed that France’s male population has the highest level of cancer-related death of any country in the EU. Scientists concluded that the soaring death rate was directly attributable to the excessive consumption of tobacco and alcohol.
Figures showed that 20% more French men die from cancer each year than British, while Sweden has the EU’s lowest male mortality rate from cancer in the EU, with 196 deaths per 100,000 compared to France’s 283.3.
According to figures collated from 1999, the most recent year for which statistics are available, France has a far larger number of deaths from mouth, lip, throat, liver and lung cancers than neighbouring countries: a clear indication of the disease’s roots in unhealthy lifestyles.
2. Epidemiology: French Kids Have ADHD—Adults, Too
Thank goodness we have more than the opinion of an MFT in an LA suburb when it comes to examining the prevalence of ADHD in France. We have skilled, experienced researchers such as Stephen V, Faraone. He is the third most highly cited researcher in psychiatry and psychology.
In 2003, Faraone and colleagues published a review of 50 epidemiologic studies. They found the mean prevalence of DSM-defined ADHD to be similar around the world (Faraone, Sergeant, Gillberg, & Biederman, 2003). That result was confirmed by a meta-analysis of epidemiologic studies (Polanczyk, de Lima, Horta, Biederman, & Rohde, 2007).
Faraone later joined other colleagues to publish Prevalence of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Associated Features Among Children in France in a 2011 issue of Journal of Attention Disorder.
Here is the paper’s conclusion:
The epidemiology of ADHD in French children is similar to the epidemiology of ADHD in other countries. The disorder occurs in between 3.5% to 5.6% of youth and is more common among boys than among girls. The authors replicate the well-known association of ADHD with CD, ODD, and indices of school failure. The impact of ADHD symptoms on school performance highlights the importance of screening for such symptoms in schools.
In the paper itself, the authors write:
Very little is known about the prevalence of ADHD in France. A literature search found no prevalence studies of ADHD in childhood and one prevalence study of ADHD in adults (Fayyad et al., 2007). This latter study examined a probability sample of 727 French adults and reported a prevalence estimate of 7.3%.
The fact that there were no pre-existing prevalence studies of ADHD in childhood in France proves only that it hadn’t been studied, not that it doesn’t exist.
The Psychoanalysts’ Lock-Hold in France
The researchers cited above do not mention that psychoanalysis has long dominated in France— far past the time when neuroscience came to inform psychiatric treatment in the United States and Canada. Perhaps it comes down to the extremely entrenched (some would say paralyzing) French bureaucracies. My French sources tell me that, no matter what your psychiatric issue, you are first offered psychoanalysis.
Yes, even for autism.
A rare critical exposure of France’s virtually closed-system came about in the 2012 documentary Le Mur, or The Wall, as reported in The New York Times’ “A French Film Takes Issue with the Psychoanalytic Approach to Autism.”
The documentary, the first film by Sophie Robert, follows two autistic boys: Guillaume, who has been treated with the behavioral, or “American,” approach; and Julien, who has been kept in an asylum for six years and treated with psychoanalysis. Guillaume, though challenged, is functioning at a high level in school. Julien is essentially silent, locked out of society.
What is really happening to French children and adults in France who have ADHD? That remains to be studied. Perhaps the strong (but rapidly eroding) social safety net is providing a degree of support. Or perhaps it is keeping them locked in a system that fails to give them greater autonomy and self-actualization—and lets them smoke and drink themselves to death.
Please see a later piece, Vive La France! But Adieu To Its Abusive “Psychiatry”, in which I examine the highly troubling roots of modern French psychiatry: a neo-Freudian figure named Jacques Lacan.